Skip to content

Carpet vs. Tile Flooring: Which Is Better?

Decades ago, it was common to see even the most luxurious of homes would have wall-to-wall-carpeting in bedrooms, living rooms, and perhaps even bathrooms. While it certainly was the design trend of its day, carpeting has largely been replaced by tile flooring as the preference of today's homeowners. However, that doesn't mean carpeting isn't used at all in many homes, and in many cases is done so due to its cheap price and installation costs. If you are preparing to give your floors a new look and are wanting to compare carpet floor tiles and other forms of tile flooring, here are some key things to remember as you make your plans.

Order Floor Tile Samples

Tile Flooring Lasts Much Longer

If you want to put down flooring and not have to worry about another installation job for decades to come, tile flooring will beat carpeting each and every time. Even with the best carpets on the market today, we at Oasis Tile have found they tend to wear out within about 10 years. However, whether you choose stone tiles or even ceramic or porcelain tiles, chances are your tile flooring may last as long as 50 years, all the while still looking like it did soon after it was installed.

A Picture of Flooring Options: Carpet, Wood Planks, and Tile


Reduced Exposure to Allergens

Whether you have dogs or cats in your home or have children who are always playing outside and then coming inside with all kinds of stuff on the bottoms of their shoes, having tile flooring will greatly reduce your family's exposure to allergens. From pet hair to pollen, these and other allergens can easily get lodged into the nooks and crannies of carpeting. However, many types of tile are resistant to pet hair, dust, and other things that can have you sneezing and sniffling.

Cost Effectiveness

In the short-term when you are comparing carpeting and tile flooring, you may think carpeting will be the smarter choice due to its somewhat lower costs and installation expenses. However, over time, you will ultimately spend more money on carpet installation than tile installation. For example, whereas you may put down tile flooring that can last 50 years, you will probably find yourself replacing your home's carpeting about five times over that same period.

Your Home's Look Stays Current

In today's world, walking into a home that still has carpet in multiple rooms immediately dates the property, and in many cases may actually decrease its value. When floor tiles of almost any type are installed, your home is instantly given a look that is crisp and sharp, which is what modern homeowners want. Whether you are planning to stay in your home for decades or expect to be selling in the years ahead, tile flooring will keep your home looking modern no matter the current design trends.

Installation Process

If there is one advantage carpeting may have over tile flooring, it is the ease of the installation process. While you can usually install carpeting on your own, some types of tiles, particularly marble, granite, and stone, often require installation by an experienced flooring contractor. However, there are also many types of tiles, including porcelain and ceramic tiles, that are very easy to install as a DIY project. 

Tile is Much Easier to Clean

If you have ever had carpeting in your home that needed to be cleaned, you remember how much of a chore it was, since it often turned into an all-day affair that yielded only so-so results. Whereas you would need a steam cleaner to rid your carpets of stains and smells, most types of floor tiles require only an occasional light mopping or wiping down with a cleaning cloth. In addition, tiles tend to be water-resistant and resistant to stains or mildew, something carpeting can't claim.

Carpet Floor Tiles

Should you like the look of carpeting and want it in a part of your home that has a low level of foot traffic, such as a bedroom, you may want to consider carpet floor tiles. Once installed, they give the same look as traditional carpeting, but are much easier to install, since they are usually of the peel and stick variety. If you choose this option for your home, we recommend a sleek carpet such as Berber, since this will be of higher-quality and be a better option than shag carpeting, which will instantly make your home look years older to guests and potential buyers.

More Colors, Designs, and Styles

While in the past some people chose to use carpeting in their bathrooms or even kitchens, they often found out this was not the best decision they ever made. More often than not, carpeting in these parts of a home wore out quickly, was always wet and stained, and was virtually impossible to clean, since it was prone to mildew. Since times have changed, tile flooring offers you more colors, designs, and styles than ever before, meaning you can transform a room's floor into almost anything you desire. In fact, you can not only get ceramic or porcelain tiles that look like wood, stone, marble, or other materials, but even get engineered wood flooring that looks just like the real thing.

Man Looking Over Selection of Wood Look Porcelain Floor Tiles

Tiles can be Customized

Even with the best carpeting, home design experts agree homeowners are limited in their ability to use it to give their homes a customized look. However, we can tell you that is absolutely not the case when it comes to floor tiles. In fact, even if you want to use natural stone tiles in your home, they can be cut to almost any size and shape, thanks to state-of-the-art waterjet technology.

Order Floor Tile Samples

The Winner? Tile Flooring by a Landslide

Offering a wide variety of colors and styles, versatility, and cost-effectiveness, our Oasis Tile team declares tile flooring to be the winner over carpeting by a landslide. If you agree with our assessment, it's time to look over our wide selection of all types of tiles. No matter what style of tile you prefer, Oasis Tile has what you need.

Related Products:

Glossy & Matte Porcelain Floor Tiles

Ceramic Wood Floor Tiles

Matte Porcelain Tiles